Devil’s Thumbprints

A recipe by Baking with Dorie

Fudgy Cookies

Our 6th recipe from Baking with Dorie is found on page 173; Devil’s Thumbprints.

The dough comes together super quickly and is a great recipe to do with kids.

Ingredients

D7E560F2-EBBD-4710-8C06-F1D8B5348A47
DC63D8C6-7FC2-4E32-824C-083AB6075567
  • I added 1/4 teaspoon espresso powder(coffee will always enhance the chocolate flavour)
  • I decreased cinnamon to 1/4 teaspoon
  • chocolate is the shining star in this recipe, use a high quality dark chocolate- minimum 70% cocoa
divider

Preparing to Bake

07FB90A4-9648-4520-BDBF-631BBD3E54E3
A2964996-851A-4D1E-A72B-8D0DE7FB22E4
33EF3ED3-0CB1-4EE5-93D8-C041FF52AA3F
  • I recommend chilling dough for 4hrs, even better if you can chill overnight
  • if you want uniform cookies invest in a cookie scoop
  • I made my cookies larger than recipe suggested, this allowed me to add more filling
divider

Filling

D1C1FF63-7EED-435D-9A8B-DCA3FBE701EC
95CAEB3C-7240-41A4-AB85-2A028281F851
  • I tried Dories recommendation for the filling; Ruby chocolate, and it was by far my favourite, out of the three I used/ the sour-tang of the ruby paired beautifully with the intensity of the dark chocolate
  • I decided to add some decorations to my cookies/ I used freeze dried raspberry chips, ruby pearls, and bronze chocolate pallets.
  • this recipe calls to bake the cookie dough before adding the jam, but I like adding the jam pre-bake so that it gets nice and warm and bakes into the dough. This gives you a slightly crunchy ring on the very edge of the cookie and a very jammy, warm center as you bite through.
divider

The Results

My rating of this recipe is 5 out of 5. I definitely will make this cookie again. I will experiment with different fillings. I also might try to make as a sandwich cookie.

This is a community cookbook club where we want to see your photos of your end result. Don't forget to tag your photos on instagram with @smidgencookbookclub or post your photo on our facebook Bake Along with Smidgen

70DC3AAA-E30A-4C65-98D2-42D26FEA2A8A
2C228B11-78ED-4008-B214-F9960CC04B0E
kitchen-smidgen-bakery-logo-gold

LOOK FOR THE BIG RED BARN

4675 Line 3
St. Marys, On

HOURS

Call in advance 

647 393 3821